## Symptom (real aufgetreten, 2026-08-11)
Ein `review_task(decision="approve")` über MCP lief >5 Min. Claude Codes MCP-Client brach den Call ab mit:
> MCP server "claudedo" tool "review_task" sent no response or progress for 300s; aborting.
Ergebnis: der Merge war **schon gelaufen und comitted** (`0e12be4`, `mergeCommit` am Worktree gesetzt), aber der Task blieb auf `WaitingForReview` hängen —
ClaudeDo-Task: d8199f1f-3df3-447f-8de2-e7aca9ec5064
wait_for_task_change resolved #<number>/bare-number ids up front via TaskIdResolver, which
throws for an unknown number -- breaking the tool's own documented promise that an unknown
id reports status "NotFound" instead of failing the whole call. Resolve per id and fall back
to the original id on a resolution failure so CheckOnceAsync can still report it.
TaskNumberAllocator.AddWithNumberAsync indexed into the app_settings UPDATE...RETURNING result
without checking for an empty result, throwing on a missing singleton row; it also caught any
DbUpdateException as a number collision, burning up to 5 numbers on an unrelated failure (e.g.
FK violation) before the real error surfaced. Now recreates the missing row and only retries on
the actual unique-index collision (SQLite error 19 on tasks.number), rethrowing everything else
immediately.
Audited the other TaskIdResolver.ResolveAsync/ResolveManyAsync call sites (ExternalMcpService,
HandoffMcpTools, ConfigMcpTools, RunHistoryMcpTools, AttachmentMcpTools, LifecycleMcpTools,
BatchMcpTools): none of their tool descriptions promise a found/NotFound flag for the id itself
(BatchMcpTools.BatchGetTasks already handles this correctly via its own per-id try/catch;
PreviewMergeSet promises a per-task "error" field, not a found/NotFound flag; the rest are
single-id tools that already throw on a missing task downstream) -- left throwing behavior as-is.
PromptFileRecovery's orphan-quarantine log only reported a bare count, so a customized
merge-helper-execute.md silently stopped applying with no pointer to where it went. Log each
quarantined file's destination path, and for merge-helper-execute.md specifically call out that
it was split into merge-helper-wait.md and merge-helper-merge.md with no content migration.
Each handoff tile is a live claude process with the full mcp__claudedo__* surface; leaving the
outgoing phase's pane open leaked one process per phase. Close it via CloseConPtySession before
opening the next phase's tile, restoring the one-pane-per-TaskId invariant so
OpenConPtySessionAsync's dedupe and OnPaneSubmitForReview can go back to FirstOrDefault.
HandoffMcpTools.HandoffListHandler only validated the phase name and
broadcast it -- nothing bounded how many times a ConPTY session could
hand off wait<->merge, so a model that skimmed past the prompt's
"final round" line could loop indefinitely. Add HandoffRoundTracker,
an in-memory per-handler-task counter (a list-handler run always
creates a fresh handler task, so no reset logic is needed): past 4
handoffs (two full wait/merge cycles) a non-final nextPhase is
coerced to its "_final" counterpart, and any handoff after a
merge_final round for that task is rejected outright.
From the 2026-08-11 unpushed-commit review (Low). Both in `src/ClaudeDo.Ui/Views/Islands/TaskRowView.axaml`. **Visual verification by the user is required — do not claim either is fixed without a screenshot; list both as open visual checks in the result.**
## A) Chain step badge is drawn under the task card
Commit `eb66ae7` moved `Border.chain-step-badge` from column 0 into column 1 with `Margin
ClaudeDo-Task: 9ec7d4ea-272b-4645-8da4-41ff3621f2f0
The 4s reconcile tick was added to three long-lived surfaces. On two of
them it reloads by rebuilding every row instance, which silently threw
away whatever the user had built up since the overlay opened; on the
third it healed a row's data but left it in the wrong section.
- WorktreesOverview: LoadAsync clears Rows, SelectedCount, ConflictRows
and BatchProgress, so batch-merge ticks, the highlighted row and a
finished batch's outcome badges were wiped every four seconds --
assembling a multi-worktree selection was impossible. Carry that state
across the reload, keyed by task id, and re-point SelectedRow at the
fresh instance (or clear it when the worktree is gone).
- MergeHelperSelection: the remember/restore had no re-entrancy guard, so
a second tick entering between the first one's reload and its restore
snapshotted rows already back at IsTickedByDefault and wrote that
default back, re-ticking what the user had unticked. One tick at a time,
and hold the row instances instead of a value snapshot so a tick landed
during the await survives.
- TasksIsland: the tick deliberately never called Regroup because Phase 2b
owned Rows in parallel. 2b has landed, so a healed task that went Done
stayed in the Open section under a stale count, and a healed depends-on
link never pulled its dependent under the chain head. Regroup when a
patch moved a grouping input, gated on a cheap key so an idle tick stays
free.
The indent column was hardcoded to 24px, so every row reserved the
gutter even with no child/chain relation. Restore Auto sizing with the
width back on the Border, which collapses to 0 while it is invisible.
Move the step badge into column 1 with a negative margin so its desired
width can never widen the Auto column (same on-screen position).
Reuses the existing 24px indent track (now gated on ShowAsChild OR
ShowAsChainMember) instead of a second mechanism, adds a round step-number
badge centered on the rail line, and a dimmed "after X" chip for chain
members whose head isn't in view or that render as a planning child.
Slice 1 of dependency-chain display: TaskRowViewModel gains DependsOnTaskId
plus the extrinsic ShowAsChainMember/ChainStep/ChainAfterLabel contract for
Slice 2's rail/badge rendering. Regroup's ClassifyItems walks each row's
DependsOnTaskId chain per section, pulls dependents directly under their
head regardless of SortOrder, and falls back to a flat row + label when the
head isn't in the same section (mirrors the ParentInView precedent).
Planning children never join a chain group - parent indent wins - and only
ever carry the label.
No AXAML changes; that's Slice 2.
Document task-number allocation in Data layer (TaskEntity.Number,
next_task_number counter, invariants, insert paths).
Update Worker docs to clarify TaskIdResolver wiring (#123 → GUID lookup),
Number in MCP payloads, and correct the 'Two hard conventions' statement
(only the first is test-enforced).
Bump external-mcp.md verified-against commit to 38af549 (Slice 4 merge)
and add new sections on task ID resolution and numbering.
Add Slice 4 visual verification items to open.md (row/detail number display,
worker-log messages).
Verified against:
- src/ClaudeDo.Data/TaskNumberAllocator.cs
- src/ClaudeDo.Data/Repositories/TaskRepository.cs (AddAsync line 20, CreateChildAsync line 276)
- src/ClaudeDo.Worker/External/TaskIdResolver.cs
- src/ClaudeDo.Worker/External/ExternalMcpService.cs (TaskDto/TaskRefDto DTOs)
- tests/ClaudeDo.Worker.Tests/External/ExternalMcpToolSchemaTests.cs (only first convention test-enforced)
Slice 4/5 of task-numbers: TaskRowViewModel.Number renders as a dimmed
"#123" before the row title; DetailsIslandViewModel.TaskIdBadge now
shows "#123" instead of the unusable "#T<guid-prefix>" handle; and the
curated WorkerLog business events in TaskRunner, TaskMergeService, and
TaskResetService prefix their quoted title with "#<Number>".
TaskIdResolver resolves a #123/bare-123 taskId parameter to its GUID
before any lookup, across every External/ MCP tool that takes a task
id, including the batch tools' id arrays (via delegation to the
already-resolving single-entity methods) and update_task's
dependsOnTaskId (empty string still passes through unchanged as the
clear-link sentinel). An unknown number throws a clear error instead
of a silent null. McpToolDocs.TaskNumberHint tells the agent to refer
to tasks as #<number> when reporting to the user, added to the
description of get_task, list_tasks, add_task, update_task_status and
review_task.
Adds Number alongside every task id in External/'s DTOs -- the two
central mappers (ToDto/ToRefDto -> TaskDto/TaskRefDto) plus every
DTO that carries a bare task id and bypasses them (batch results,
queue state, wait-for-change, config, attachments, handoff,
lifecycle, merge-preview-set, worktree list). Input resolution
(#123 as an argument) stays for slice 3.
The task-numbers slice added a UNIQUE index on tasks.number. Ui.Tests seed
TaskEntity rows directly instead of going through TaskRepository, so every row
kept the default Number = 0 and 31 tests failed with
'UNIQUE constraint failed: tasks.number'.
TaskEntity.Number is a global, monotonically increasing, never-reused
integer (displayed as #123), allocated from AppSettingsEntity.NextTaskNumber
via a single UPDATE...RETURNING statement rather than MAX(number)+1, which
would reissue a deleted task's number. Both insert paths (TaskRepository.
AddAsync and CreateChildAsync) route through the new TaskNumberAllocator,
with a bounded retry on a unique-index collision. One migration adds the
columns, backfills existing rows in creation order, and creates the unique
index afterwards. Data-layer only; MCP/UI wiring is later slices.
HandoffRequested now carries nextPhase end to end (IWorkerClient ->
WorkerClient -> MissionControlViewModel -> GetMergeHelperHandoffLaunchSpecAsync),
and the outgoing tile is left open on handoff instead of being closed --
lookups that need the active pane for a task now use LastOrDefault since a
handler task's ConPtySessions can hold more than one pane.
Threads a nextPhase parameter (wait/merge/wait_final/merge_final, validated
by the new MergeHelperPhase) from handoff_list_handler through
HubBroadcaster/WorkerHub into InteractiveLaunchSpecService, which now picks
the next session's system prompt (MergeHelperWait/MergeHelperMerge) and
model (HandlerWaitAlias/HandlerMergeAlias) from it instead of hardcoding the
old two-phase Execute prompt -- this also fixes a build break left by the
prior prompt-split task, which removed PromptKind.MergeHelperExecute without
updating its only caller.
Also sets --model/--effort/--permission-mode explicitly for every list-handler
session (Triage included) via PermissionModeResolver instead of inheriting the
CLI's ambient model and hardcoding "auto", and adds Task to the merge-helper
allowlist so the Merge phase can delegate diff reviews to subagents.
Avalonia 12 leaves ScrollViewer.Padding out of the scroll Extent, so at
maximum offset the content still overhangs the viewport by the padding
height — the last lines were cut off and unreachable even after
ScrollToEnd(). Move the inset onto the content (Margin on the inner
ItemsControl/StackPanel) and leave the ScrollViewer padding-free.
Affects the work console Output/Git/Session tabs, the reusable session
terminal (task + prep log) and the log visualizer.
Adds HandlerTriageAlias/HandlerWaitAlias/HandlerMergeAlias to ModelRegistry and
replaces PromptKind.MergeHelperExecute with MergeHelperWait (phase 3 only) and
MergeHelperMerge (phases 4-5), so the list handler can run as three
cost-scoped sessions instead of two. Triage's Phase 2 now checks/sets a wide
verify command via get_list_config/set_list_config once per run. Merge now
merges before reruns, delegates diff review to a sonnet subagent, rejects
0-file diffs, tracks the merged-but-not-Done verify-gate outcome, and caps
reruns at one per task via handoff_list_handler's new nextPhase parameter.
InteractiveLaunchSpecService.cs still references the removed
PromptKind.MergeHelperExecute and fails to build -- wiring the Worker/UI side
onto the new roles is a follow-up task.
SetListConfig previously could only pass VerifyCommand through unchanged;
only the UI hub could set it. Add an optional verifyCommand parameter with
matching clear/merge/create-vs-delete handling, and split the list result
into ListConfigDto so the task-only SetTaskConfig/GetTaskConfig DTOs stay
untouched. Also corrects Worker/CLAUDE.md's claim that tasks can override
verify_command — it's list-only.
Shorten the review-prompt placeholder and localize it (session.reviewFeedbackPlaceholder,
en+de) instead of a hardcoded string that overran the narrow column. Switch the growing
TextBox's VerticalContentAlignment from Center to Top so multi-line input grows downward
instead of being clipped top/bottom, add an auto scrollbar past MaxHeight, and top-align
the prompt glyph and Resume button to match.
Cards touched with Margin=0. Add margin on the inner task-row border
instead of the ListBoxItem style, so the drag/drop hit-test container
still covers the row and the drop-hint doesn't flicker between items.
A list working_dir stored as "C:\Dev\Tests\StaplerTracking\" broke every consumer
that puts it on a Windows command line: argv rules read \" as an escaped quote, so
the token never closes. "Open in terminal" passed wt.exe a starting directory of
C:\Dev\Tests\StaplerTracking" and it failed with 0x8007010b; the same data had
already corrupted the ConPTY list handler's arg list in August.
Paths.TrimTrailingSeparator is now the single helper (replacing the copies in
InteractiveLaunchSpecService and ClaudeHelpLauncher) and ListRepository applies it
on Add/Update, which covers every writer: UI create, repo import, hub UpdateList,
and MCP CreateList/UpdateList. OpenInTerminal also switches to ArgumentList so its
quoting is correct regardless of what's stored.
AddScopeOverlapFields, AddTaskDependency and AddFailureReason were each
generated off the same parent migration, so none of their Designer
snapshots knows the others' columns. AddTaskDependency calls AddForeignKey,
which on SQLite forces a full `tasks` table rebuild generated from that
migration's own frozen snapshot -- silently recreating the table without
`scope_globs`.
Result: the Worker died at startup with "no such column: t.scope_globs"
(Hosting failed to start), so it never bound the SignalR port and the App
could not connect. Fresh installs were affected too, not just existing DBs.
Add the missing ScopeGlobs property to the stale Designer snapshot so the
rebuild preserves the column. Verified by migrating a fresh temp DB and
diffing pragma_table_info('tasks') against the model snapshot: 39/39
columns.
Note: the test suite cannot catch this class of bug -- every fixture uses
Database.EnsureCreated(), which builds the schema from the model and never
applies the migration chain.
Phase 2b-1 moved the group headers from {loc:Tr} bindings in TasksIslandView
into HeaderRow.Label, resolved once in Regroup(). RefreshLocalizedText only
updated CompletedHeader and the task rows, so after switching the language the
three section headers kept the old one. Re-run Regroup() there.
Not unit-tested: the only seam is the global static Loc.Current, and mutating
it would bleed into test classes running in parallel.
mika kuns